Just some thoughts. I appreciate your feedback, and to others, you wont hurt my feelings if you tell me our software sucks.Im aware of several other valve sizing programs in the market today from Consolidated, Fisher and Ferris as well.
Im curious if anyone has ever used SafetySize and what they think about the program. Consolidated Psv Sizing How To Build TheirConsolidated Psv Sizing Download It AndHow does it compare to other programs you have used What really bothers you about vendor sizing programs What kind of things would you like to see in a valve sizing program from a vendor If you could tell the vendor how to build their program what would you tell them If you have never used our program we have a new website at where you can download it and let me know what you think. Im trying to create a site there that is useful to all valve engineers by providing content. Id be interested in feedback you might have about the site or any of our programs. Id like to be able to give people a good place to go for information about valve sizing. Thats why I have put a link back to this forum, I think this place is a great resource. You are the users of these systems so Im interested in what you would like to see. However, and sorry, but Im not a fan of any canned software for PSV sizing, I find a spreadsheet does quite well. The real effort is understanding the system, performing the analysis and determining relieving rates. Consolidated Psv Sizing Simulator Is SometimesFor this a good process simulator is sometimes needed, not canned PSV sizing software. Some of what may be easier relief scenarios, e.g.blocked-in (pumping or compressores), control valve failure, are easily handled with a spreadsheet. A less experienced Process Engineer shouldnt even be doing these type of calculations without the guidance of an experienced Process Engineer. I will grant you that your software (and the others) will be able to produce the data sheet but then I get your specific valve and perhaps I dont want your specific valve. OK, so I can customize the data sheet for a generic valve, then what is the difference if I set up my own spreadsheet The beauty of your company wesite and others is that us Process Engineers can get the information we need to make intelligent decisions on what products are out there and their applications. I almost put that as a choice in my poll but figured everyone would vote for it which isnt what I wanted. Im looking to see if there is a preference within that list of programs. I guess if you already know you want to purchase a Consolidated, Ferris, Tyco valve then the programs make sense, but for generic sizing they might not. And to your point, its not rocket science, nor is it proprietary. I guess there is some value in retaining a history of your valves, but again youve already chosen a vendor when you use their program. So sizing is straight forward, its the selection part that is not so clear. Once the valve is sized you get a list of models that you can select as your selection. What if there was a generic sizing engine that allows you to select the generic size of valve not a vendor specific model, then it gave you a list of options so you were at least able to create a nice report for your vendor maybe its not a Tyco valve you want but its a nice program for you to keep a history of the valves you sized and generate reports. Granted the configuration would have nothing intelligent about it, but a list of options for you pick. Just some thoughts. I appreciate your feedback, and to others, you wont hurt my feelings if you tell me our software sucks.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Details
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |